'Mobile Women' of Mongla bridging digital divide
Barnaby Skinner, back from Mongla
THE remote villages of Mongla are experiencing a mobile phone frenzy. Algae in shrimp farms are disappearing, the pharmacist knows which medication to buy and the Hindu carpenter and his wife can finally talk to somebody about the nasty disease of their guava tree. All thanks to mobile phones.
At the beginning of 2005, the Bangladesh organisation 'Development through Access to Network Resources' (Dnet) selected four women from remote villages, gave them a mobile phone and said: "Bring it to your neighbours. Call us in Dhaka and tell them to ask us anything they want to know about farming, education, health or law."
Ten months on, the Dnet-project 'Mobile Women' has finalised its piloting phase. The project was so successful that the mobile network market leader GrameenPhone has approached Dnet and wants to supply 60,000 women with a mobile phone and set up just as many regional information centres all over the country based on the Dnet model.
Yamin Bakht, GrameenPhone spokes person, says, "We are at a very preliminary stage, but Dnet's project is very impressive. We are interested in picking up the model, yes."
How does this project work? The Daily Star spent a day with the mobile woman in Mongla, Nayan Mondol, to see what hat caught GrameenPhone's attention on such a large scale.
Nayan Mondol is 21 years old, she's Hindu and she was all set for a life working in her parent's vegetable garden before she heard about the mobile women project. "I didn't leave home much", she says. Now, where ever she goes, people greet her with a friendly smile and ask: "When will you be visiting us next?"
Mondol is the second mobile woman in Mongla. The first one, Ebika Biswas (29), had a tough time promoting her service at first. Nobody trusted her and her phone. She, however, made a breakthrough, when she helped shrimp farmers to reduce the algae in their ponds by breeding fish with shrimps. Since then, Biswas and Mondol are welcome everywhere.
Today, dressed in white and blue garments, wearing plastic sandals and golden ear rings Nayan Mondol sets out in the late morning for South Kainmari. The trip means a shaky one-hour van-ride on the neatly cobbled roads that link the 77 villages of Mongla.
She starts her tour of South Kainmari at the village doctor, Ashish Biswas. Sitting in his tight stall, surrounded by medication against diarrhoea, headache and fever he greets her warmly. He wants to know, if there are any new products against diarrhoea and how expensive they are. Mondol takes out the phone she had carefully stashed in her handbag before the van-ride and says: "A health issue." She looks up the health number in the phone directory and connects the doctor with the information offices in Dhaka. He places his request and within three minutes he knows what he wants. The health office in Dhaka promises to send him a detailed price list within a week.
Biswas pays by the minute for the call. In total Tk 12. Before the mobile woman service, he would have had to travel to the next largest city Khulna; time consuming and very costly.
Mondol's next stop is at the tailor's. Last week, Dipali Mazumder wanted to know, if their might be any connection between her daughter's headache and hearing problems. Mondol has the answer of Mazumder's request in her bag in a printout from the regional office at Mongla port. Every day the Dhaka office sends answers to more complex questions on CD-ROM, which are then printed and delivered.
Then Mondol goes to see the carpenter Arabunda Bagchi and his wife Mamata. "The guava tree in front of our house is dying. It has these funny white spots and doesn't bear fruit anymore", Arabundi Bagchi says. "An agricultural question", Mondol confirms and hands Mamata the phone. "My wife's better at using it", the carpenter says. However, he does get a little nervous as she seems to have picked up chatting on the phone quite quickly. Considering the cost of Tk 4 per minute a costly habit for the Bagchis.
Not all villagers are as easy with the phone as Mamata Bagchi. Their neighbour, Sabita Roy, who has a question concerning her own health, prefers to submit her question in a letter. Half of Mongla's population are illiterate. Mondol does the writing for them. However, she complains: "Letters take too long. Especially for health issues. And sometimes, in the case of minor questions, people have forgotten their original question, when I get the answer to them." Dnet have high hopes that this will soon change. By the end of the year GrameenPhone will cover the whole country with EDGE-technology, a step up from simple GSM. AKTEL already has GPRS, also a technology that offers simpler and quicker access to the Internet and email.
Back in Dhaka Ananya Raihan, the director in-charge of all Dnet activities, is very happy with the mobile women and their work. Shortly before leaving for Tunis to present his project at the World Summit of Information Society (WSIS) in Tunis (November 16-17), he said: "It seems, we have finally found a way to bridge the digital divide using a very limited infrastructure." He points out that this service is far more valuable than just setting up an internet connection in a village. It is also a counselling line. Dnet tells people, how to implement the information they can acquire.
However, maintaining the information centres is the central problem. Raihan explains: "We are a research centre, we don't do business. We understand that there is a demand for this service. But we are not yet sure, how to finance the maintenance of the information and our central and regional call centres long term."
Mobile women currently earn Tk 2,200 a month. Then there are the phone and calling costs to take into account. "The current pricing at Tk 4 per minute covers this", Raihan says and adds, "but now we need to find a way to cover the costs of the information centres." This can only be achieved by raising the price of each call substantially. And will villages be able to afford the service then?
Raihan estimates set-up costs of a regional centres gathering at around Tk 30,000, operating costs are Tk 12,000 a month. "We need another year to work out, how to make a business case out of this", says Raihan, "as soon as we have done this, I will be quite happy with GrameenPhone modelling our project.
At present, Raihan believes that implementation of Dnet's model by GrameenPhone should be taken slowly as the business case has not been sorted out as of yet.
Clockwise: Ebika Biswas, the first Mobile Women talks to The Daily Star about how she convinced the villager to use her service; The tailor, Dipali Mazumder, finally discusses her daughter's health issues with an expert on the phone; Nayon Mandal goes around the village to offer her service & Nayon Mandal documents the questions while the village doctor speaks to the heath desk at the information centre in Dhaka. PHOTO: Syed Zakir Hossain