The Daily Star

Your Right To Know
Sunday, February 14, 2016

Tuesday, March 1, 2011
Front Page

BB Letter To Finance Ministry

Yunus beyond legal age limit

Grameen Bank chairman presents it at board meeting

The chairman of Grameen Bank yesterday presented a letter at a board meeting that questioned the post of Professor Muhammad Yunus as its managing director beyond his retirement age.

The letter was written by a Bangladesh Bank official to the finance ministry expressing an opinion that Prof Yunus continued to hold the post beyond his retirement age of 60, which was not lawful.

And no endorsement was obtained for this from Bangladesh Bank, said Khondaker Muzammel Huq, chairman of Grameen Bank, who received a copy of the letter.

Muzammel, a former employee who had served under Yunus, has recently been appointed by the government as chairman of Grameen. Yesterday's meeting with Grameen directors came in the wake of a controversy surrounding the micro-lender.

Quoting the letter, Muzammel told The Daily Star that Yunus has been staying in the post for an indefinite period, which is not within the law.

In response to queries from The Daily Star, Jannat-E-Quanine, general manager of Grameen Bank, said: "We cannot make any comments on board proceedings or discuss anything that relates to the board meeting.”

“We can confirm that no letter addressed to Professor Muhammad Yunus has been received from Bangladesh Bank.”

“The chairman of the Grameen Bank Board is referring to a letter addressed to the Ministry of Finance where it is understood that a Bangladesh Bank official has expressed an opinion regarding Professor Yunus's term as managing director.”

“There is no directive on Professor Yunus to cease functioning as managing director, nor is there any suggestion of his being removed from this post. Professor Yunus continues to be in his position as the managing director of Grameen Bank.”

Meanwhile, news agency AFP reported that Bangladesh moved to force Nobel prize winner Muhammad Yunus out of his pioneering microfinance bank, with the central bank saying he had passed retirement age and had to go.

Supporters of the 70-year-old Yunus, including former Irish president Mary Robinson, say there is a campaign of politically orchestrated attacks on the Nobel laureate after he fell out with Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina in 2007.

Bangladesh Bank sent a letter to the finance ministry saying that Yunus, who won the Nobel prize in 2006 for his work making small loans to poor entrepreneurs, should be removed from the Grameen Bank he founded.

"In the letter -- a copy of which has been given to me -- the central bank said he no longer can stay as the chief executive of the Grameen Bank because the retirement age of the bank is 60,” said Grameen Bank Chairman Muzammel Huq.

Hence, him being the bank chief executive is "illegal and not valid," Huq said, reading out the letter to AFP.

A Bangladesh Bank official said the finance ministry can now remove Yunus because the government holds a 25 percent stake in the micro-lender.

"We told the finance ministry his overstaying as the chief executive clearly flouted section number 14(1) of the Grameen Bank laws," the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

The move comes as Yunus faces intense pressure from the government to quit his post. In early February, Finance Minister AMA Muhith asked the Nobel winner to go.

Following the release of a Norwegian documentary in December which accused Yunus and Grameen of malpractice, Yunus has been vilified in the Bangladeshi press and seen his bank become the target of a government investigation.

After the release of the documentary, the Norwegian government opened an investigation and expressed its full satisfaction over the use of its funds.

Share on


I am sure, there are better and nobler ways of dealing with the only Nobel laureate from independent Bangladesh than to vilify him ruthlessly with a covert or over political agenda. I still want to believe that the prime minister and the finance minister of the country can do stand on a higher moral ground to prevent this theater of the absurd from unfolding.

: Faridul Alam, PhD

Shame!Bangladesh Bank should at least wait till the final investigation report is being submitted.Unfortunate situation for the nation.Humility is not the proper answer.Of course they should think about the 10 Million poor and distress people especially women who are the direct and indirect beneficiaries of Grameen Bank and its subsidiaries and also sister concerns.

: Kanchan


  • Swadeshi 2011
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 01:37 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    This kind of event is an insult to the people of Bangladesh. The immaturity of these petty bureaucrats against Dr Yunus does us injustice. I believe the Finance Minister is over 75 years old! Shouldn't he resign as well? Are there others in the Cabinet above age 60? They too should resign!

  • Sawgat Chowdhury
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 02:06 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    How old Bangladesh finance minister? if he is 60 or above, he is not capable to make sound decision. Let him step down. Or this stupid law must be changed.

  • Anonymous
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 02:51 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    So what? Give him extension as is the case with the government officials.

  • Jihad
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 02:39 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    No one above the law. But it's sad to see how some people try to hang on to the job even after their retirement age had passed. It's just greed & lust for power.

  • M. Akhtar
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 05:57 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    Professor Yunus like any other nobel winner should be kept beyond the reach of the intellectual pygmies let alone the questions of age and corruption. He is our only unquestionable pride. If a guy like Mozammel who had served under Prof. Yunus and wants to sit in his chare, wishes to talk about age, he should look at his Finance Minister who is much older and fainted in the JS. This is ungrateful.

  • Anonymous, UK
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 06:02 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    I gave a search in the Google I failed to find the name Muzammel with any notable publications or citations. How could he dare make comments like he did about a nobel laureate recognized by the whole world? Shame on the those who are doing ugly politics to take revenge on Prof. Yunus for not giving them the stage they do not deserve.

  • Dr . Karim
    Tuesday, March 1, 2011 06:29 AM GMT+06:00 (259 weeks ago)

    I am surprised to see BB became so honest suddenly. BB should see national interest more than sector interest and should be transparent.Economist Dr MR Debnath specifically asked the question about twelve thousand crores of Taka doesnt have any existence and manipulated by nationalised big banks ,sent by remitters like myself and others .Why BB are not vocal about that. Currently power of ACC has been cut down and public service sections are coming out again.Please be transparent ,pledged by BB governor dr Atiur Rahman who shouldnt take side on any corruption.





The Daily Star

©, 1991-2016. All Rights Reserved