The Daily Star

Your Right To Know
Sunday, February 7, 2016

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Strategically Speaking

Conspiracy theory: Fig leaf of an excuse

(L-R)Photo: Habibul Haque/ Driknews, Prabir Das

That we are alive is an accident and not the other way round. And nowhere is it more palpably demonstrated regularly than Bangladesh. The two shocking incidents, the girder collapse of an under construction flyover in Chittagong and the Ashulia fire that took the lives of more than 100 people, not only reconfirm the fact that it is because of sheer providence that we get to see the sun rise every morning, these also reveal two aspects most vividly -- one, the authorities' utter disregard for the safety and security of human lives, particularly of the poor workers, and two, the ill effects of blatant partisan consideration in handing out government contracts for public works.

This is the second time that a part of the said flyover has collapsed. On the first occasion the mishap occurred on a holiday and thus it was an act of providence that there was no casualty. The second time twelve unwary people, passing under the construction site that had little arrangements to protect the people from falling debris, were killed. It was not credentials but political links of the construction firm which was the prime determinant of awarding the contract. The project is there because of politics and not public need, and, reportedly, the project director was sacked before on corruption charges. What a love for mendacity!

Ashulia is the worst RMG factory disaster in Bangladesh. And since Saturday we have been seeing pathetic attempts in the electronic media by various people belonging to the fraternity of garment manufacturers and exporters to seek an excuse and justify the deaths, anything that will provide a sliver of an opportunity for absolving themselves from the responsibility.

We have heard the BGMEA bosses crying hoarse about Tazreen Fashions being a compliant factory. If so, why the access road was so constricted, which even a jackass could determine as being unsuitable to serve a factory of that size? But no, not the factory inspectors, not the BGMEA inspection teams, and not even the fire service inspectors who are supposed to inspect and give a survey report of such buildings, could determine the inadequacy of access and exit of the factory. Every single safety measure was violated in every conceivable way and the building was so faulty that it became a veritable deathtrap, a fact missed by the inspectors. And yet the BGMEA feels no qualms to give it a clean chit.

No wonder that people are clinging to the arson /conspiracy theory as a last straw. If it was not arson some other excuse would have been manufactured. Have we not desecrated the dead of Ashulia already by initially intending to dispose them off in a hurry through a mass ritual, without even making so much of an attempt to use modern facilities to identify them and hand them over to their relatives? Sanity prevailed at the end when on government instructions the medical colleges conducted their DNA tests. But then, after having been reduced to ashes these unfortunate victims are now reduced to mere numbers. That, unfortunately, is the lot of the poor in Bangladesh. And the offer of a hundred thousand taka as compensation per victim is a cruel joke.

The arson theory comes as a very handy excuse, but is not even a fig leaf to cover the faults, and there are many faults for which responsibility must be owned up by people at various levels of the management, the BGMEA and of course the government.

With five different committees set up by various agencies one wonders what the outcome of the exercise would be. There are two things that the government must focus on without proffering theories even before the formation of the inquiry committees. First, it must find out how the fire broke out. And nobody should discount the possibility of arson and sabotage.

It might well have been a case of arson but that does not in any way absolve the persons responsible for ensuring the safety and security of the workers, which is the second aspect the committees must go into.

Those who passed the building plan must be held to account for the faulty structure as much as those that gave it the fitness certificate to run as a factory. The BGMEA must answer for turning a blind eye to all the shortcomings, and the fire department must do likewise for not having it shut down for failing to meet safety requirements.

I say all these knowing fully well that nothing at all will happen to the guilty. The owner of Tazreen is in hiding and no effort has been made to apprehend him. Nothing will happen to them because the RMG factory owners not only earn huge foreign exchange they run the politics in the country too. Very soon the matter will die down, most of the owners will continue to bask in the profits earned at the expense of "cheap labour," some will continue to replace their Pajeros with SUVs or something similarly filthily expensive every year, and a few will go off to some exotic place with their families to avoid the rush on public holidays, till another Tazreen.

The writer is Editor, Op-Ed and Strategic Issues, The Daily Star.

Share on


Today the Tazreen Fashion Ltd. Managing Director in an interview with the Daily Star has spoken specifically that Wal-Mart was very much present on their premises and issue of compliance was raised by the big buyer, but not on the safety matters, but other issues. That’s fine enough to prove that US giant Wal-Mart cannot possibly wash their hand away from it. It was equally very puzzling and mind boggling to see how quickly the PM, Home Minister MKA along with two other politicians came up with the conspiracy theory. I find this as more damaging claim which will become a boomerang. Time has come to question the BGMEA and BKMEA seriously; we people do not think that they are really interested in the welfare of the poor worker who is basically their main source of competitiveness. Both of these two organisations tried to protect the interest of the industry owners rather than victim workers. Their shrewd maneuvering in the alley of power is very much visible as they are able to buy their way to the top with their newly found wealth. Time has come to challenge their authority and power. To stat that process we must make sure that BGMEA Bhaban is declared illegal immediately and demolish it without any time loss. If the authority does not do it now, people may do the task, I fear. We must allow healthy collective bargain agency (CBA) activities as per standard labour law of the country as ILO signatory and WTO member country. This is a must as BGMEA & BKMEA became simply too powerful due to this single cause which allowed the workers to be neglected in this sector for such a long period.

: Sheikh Monirul Islam, Opee

A beautiful and very timely summation. Tongues that have already started wagging to divert attention from the guilty should stop.

: jilanee


  • Saleh Md. Shahriar
    Thursday, November 29, 2012 10:08 AM GMT+06:00 (166 weeks ago)

    Conspiracy is secondary. The primary thing is that the government has failed in removing the alleged conspiracy. The state intelligence agencies are perhaps sleeping.





The Daily Star

©, 1991-2016. All Rights Reserved