Committed to PEOPLE'S RIGHT TO KNOW
Vol. 4 Num 259 Wed. February 18, 2004  
   
Point-Counterpoint


Gaddafi's tryst with the US?


Gaddafi is a seasoned ruler of Libya who is known all over the world for his mercurial personality. In younger days in the 70s and 80s, he was combative and his speech was full of fury and polemics. However, lately the shrewd politician is showing signs of old age. His latest move vis-à -vis his tortuous relationship with the West in the immediate past has puzzled most Gaddafi watchers. Just in the last year, he has metamorphosed into a docile person. Gone are the vitriolic criticisms of the West. He has settled all his scores with the West concerning the ill-fated Pan Am flight 103 that was downed over Lockerbie, Scotland in December 1988 by Libyan agents. His country agreed to pay the punitive damages to the family members of passengers who were killed in that mid air blast. Gaddafi again surprised his critics by agreeing to dismantle Libya's nuclear weaponry programme. He went so far as to ask America to take materials from his bomb-making factory. Very recently radioactive compounds, most likely weapon-grade uranium, were hauled by transport planes to Oakridge, Tennessee. The gesture of becoming a good guy in the eyes of the West has brought condemnation from Arab world and elsewhere, but Col. Gaddafi is unperturbed. All indications are that he wants to be viewed by the West as a docile person who had renounced all forms of violence. This is very uncharacteristic of him. Nonetheless, that is what he has done.

Unbeknownst to most Gaddafi watchers, his 31-year old son Seif al-Islam Gaddafi and who is rumoured heir apparent to the dictator believes his father has cut a very good deal with the West. In a recent interview given to Carla Anne Robbins of WSJ in Tripoli Seif Gaddafi said, "It's a package deal. They have to reward us in order to make us an example." What he meant by this is Libya can play a role model for the radical transformation of a rogue nation to become a law-abiding country in the comity of nations. The bigger question however is whether Iran, Syria, and North Korea would follow Libya's example.

The Bush Administration is wary of hugging Col. Gaddafi, especially in an election year for the fear that Sen. Kerry of Massachusetts, who in all probability would run against Mr. Bush this coming fall, might criticise the incumbent president for hobnobbing with an unpredictable dictator. We however know for sure that Mr. Bush will take all the credit for Col. Gaddafi's recent transformation in the post 9-11 days from a hawk to a sheep. Mr. Bush may say that his "get-tough-policy" with the rogue nations and his war efforts against Mullah Omar's regime and Saddam did bring this unexpected result. We already hear that sentiment when Mr. Bush proclaimed on February 11, 2004, "Col. Gaddafi made the right decision, and the world will be safer once his commitment is fulfilled. We expect other regimes to follow his examples." As the campaign for White House moves into high gear after Labour Day, Mr. Bush will cite the example of Col. Gaddafi's transformation over and over to score a point for his highhandedness policy vis-à

-vis rogue nations. Sen. Kerry may cite the Dr. Qadeer Khan fiasco relating to the sale of nuclear technology and Mr. Bush not reprimanding Gen. Pervez Musharraf. Stay tuned. This year's presidential campaign is going to turn pretty nasty in the coming fall.

Many experts think that after all these years Col. Gaddafi blinked because he saw what did happen to Saddam Hussein. Come to think of it, Gaddafi is a tad smarter than Saddam. He wanted to be in the catbird seat in Tripoli. This was the way he could cajole the Bush Administration. His timing was just absolutely right. In an election year, Mr. Bush may use Gaddafi's transformation from being a rogue ruler to a law-abiding citizen of the world far too many times. In the meantime, Libyans can relax now. The U.S. planes are not about to fly over Tripoli delivering powerful 'Daisy-cutter' bombs. All Gaddafi could care is preservation of his power. Thus, what other leaders or clerics say about his kowtowing with Mr. Bush hardly matters to him.

Gaddafi's son Seif and many more Libyans like him tend to think that the West does not care much about the reasons why Col. Gaddafi decided to become a lamb at this juncture. First, the erratic socialist regime Col. Gaddafi heads could not produce any discernible change in Libya's economy. Add to this the last two decades sanctions imposed by the West. Thus, Libya's oil revenue was squandered by the regime just to feed the population (a reminiscence of Saddam's policy to remain popular amongst his people). The country did not make progress in agricultural sector even though Col. Gaddafi's polemics filled the pages of his famous "Green Book." Under this dire backdrop, Libya has produced a new crop of citizens who received training in the West and who has embraced private enterprise. These "New Libyans" have guided Col. Gaddafi to embrace globalisation, free market economy, membership in the WTO. They do not want to see Libya remains a pariah state. On top of this, Libya's emerging middle class has become frustrated with their leader's policy to turn the economy into stagnation. Libya could have easily used her oil revenue to build the nation. But under the terrible spectre of being a rogue state, which actively supported global terrorism, the oil revenue was wasted. The nation could not make headway to progress.

The Libyan leader is now 62 years of age. He deposed King Idris in a bloodless coup in 1969 when he was only 27 year old and a junior officer, only Captain, in Libyan army. During 1973 through 1977, he banned all private enterprises and ostensibly transferred power to local people's committee. He also compiled his famous "Green Book," which was filled with his quotable quotes a la Mao Tse-tung's "Red Book." Through 1981-1986, Gaddafi championed global terrorism by aiding various terrorist organisations. In retaliation to his activities to promote terrorism the U.S. banned travel, trade, and investment in Libya. The U.S. plane even bombed Gaddafi's tent barely missing him in those raids. During 1992-1993, the U.N. imposed sanctions against Libya over two suspects mastermind of the Pan Am bombing in December 1988. Realising that the West has evidences implicating the two Libyan suspects in 1988 blasting of the Pan Am jetliner in Scotland, Gaddafi ordered handing over the two Libyan intelligence officers.

The U.N. revoked its sanctions against Libya but the U.S. policy remained the same. After 9-11 incidents, Col. Gaddafi saw the proverbial "light" for the very first time. In August 2003, Libya accepted responsibility for the downing of Pan Am 103 and agreed to pay compensation to victims' families. In a surprising move in December 2003, Libya agreed to disclose and destroy its nuclear and chemical weapons programmes. In January 2004, the U.S. removed from Libyan nuclear plans and the first shipment of nuclear related equipment and materials were flown to Oakridge, Tennessee, USA.

In the meantime, the new generation of Libyans heave a sigh of relief knowing that Col. Gaddafi has changed his mind vis-à-vis his support for global terrorism. Gaddafi's son Seif quipped, "Now, finally we are catching up with the times." Seif Gaddafi is a pragmatic young man who is a doctoral student in global governance at the prestigious LSE in Britain. Even though Mr. Seif Gaddafi has no official role, nonetheless he represents the newer generation of Libyans who want to see the oil-rich nation embark onto modernisation a la western style.

Many reforms are now taking place in Libya. In mid 1970s, Col. Gaddafi had proclaimed, "land is the private property of none" (source: Gaddafi's Green Book). But now private ownership to land, state-owned companies including cement, shoe, soft-drink bottling companies, banks, and possibly part of the giant oil companies -- all will be in the auction block. The government has embraced an aggressive privatisation plan.

Col. Gaddafi's mercurial temperament had made him a legend in Muslim world. The first thing he did after deposing King Idris in 1969 was to promote him from the lowly rank of Captain to Colonel. He then abolished the Latin alphabet from street signs. By the mid 1970s, he was promoting his own ideology, which he dubbed as "The Third Universal Theory." Earlier he tried to float a new "Pan Arab Union" only to promote him as the supreme Arab leader. The plan went awry because Egypt's Anwar El-Sadat and other Arab leaders thought Gaddafi was merely a crackpot. Gaddafi then turned his attention to terrorist organisations all over the globe. This action of Gaddafi brought condemnation from many western nations. The Reagan Administration banned the importation of crude oil from Libya.

In 1986, the U.S. warplanes bombed Tripoli and Benghazi in retaliation to terrorist bombing of a Berlin discothèque. In the aerial bombing raid, 40 Libyans were killed. It was rumored at the time that Gaddafi's own daughter was killed in the bombing. Two years later in December 1988, a passenger jetliner belonging to Pan Am was downed in Scotland. The Libyan connection was established immediately. After 16 years of the downing of Pan Am jetliner, now Libya has accepted the guilt. They will be shelling out about 2.7 billion dollars compensation to the relatives of Lockerbie victims. After the U.S. had occupied both Afghanistan and Iraq in a move to weed out global terrorism, the Libyan strongman has seen the divine light. Outwardly, he could be deemed as a madcap despot but internally he is a terrified man. He has blinked now. He wants to save his face and his country from the wrath of Uncle Sam.

There are telltale signs in Libya that Col. Gaddafi's grip on power is slipping fast. Even though his giant size portraits -- in military uniform and Arab robes -- still grace the offices, shops, and street corners, but hardly anyone talks about him. This was reported in western newspapers. There is hardly any democracy in Libya. People are afraid to talk about Col. Gaddafi in public. In late 2001, Col. Gaddafi decided to usher in free market in Libya but as far as political reform is concerned, he steadfastly refuses to give green light to liberalise the political system in this oil-rich nation. By African standard, Libya is a rich country with oil revenue of $13 billion. Gaddafi's government provides food subsidies to all Libyans. Thus, he buys off dissent with food subsidies. Iraq's deposed leader Saddam Hussein also followed the same practice. However, lately, the oil production in Libya has faltered and economic activity inside the country is at best stagnant. Some economists think that Libya's unemployment rate is as high as 30 per cent. With oil prices down and corruption among government officials heading up, Libyans are having their doubts for a bright prospect for their future generation. By late 1990s, Col. Gaddafi also felt that he had enough with his social and political experimentations. He severed his ties with terrorist groups. After 9-11 incident Col. Gaddafi denounced the attack on America by al-Qaeda terrorists. Two years ago in spring 1999, Libya's intelligence chief reportedly approached U.S. officials offering to share information on al-Qaeda.

The Europeans are now looking at Libya from a different angle. The British PM, Tony Blair, would soon meet a reformed Col. Gaddafi. As I alluded to earlier, the 9-11 terrorist attacks and the impending war in Afghanistan and Iraq had changed Gaddafi's mind; he is now serious about making peace with the U.S. Col. Gaddafi is a reformed leader now. Therefore, many U.S. lawmakers think that Libya should be rewarded so that Gaddafi continues to tread the new path. In the first week of February 2004, the U.S. Assistant Secretary of State, Mr. William Burns, met with Libya's intelligence chief and two senior Libyan diplomats in London to talk about the upcoming dismantling of weapon-developing plans that Gaddafi regime has taken up. The U.S. now wants to set up a diplomatic office in Tripoli. They are asking the Libyans to do the same in Washington D.C. The U.S. oil companies who had presence in Libyan will be allowed to renew contracts. All indications are that the bilateral relationship between the U.S. and Libya is going to improve in the coming days.

In summary, the mercurial leader of Libya, Col. Gaddafi, has seen the "light" finally. He now wants to mend the fence with the Americans. To improve his country's relationship with the U.S., he has changed his long-held policy to abet terrorist organisations. Libya is now going to pay $ 2.7 billion compensation to the families of Lockerbie plane disaster. Col. Gaddafi is also dismantling the weapons development plan in Libya. All indications are that a sea change in attitude has taken place in Gaddafi. Had Saddam has this foresight perhaps there won't be any Iraq War in March 2003.

Dr. A.H. Jaffor Ullah, a researcher, stays in New Orleans, USA.