Committed to PEOPLE'S RIGHT TO KNOW
Vol. 5 Num 959 Sat. February 10, 2007  
   
Literature


the mailbag
Movie Criticism: A Response
This writing is a response to Rebecca Sultana's 'Of Paan, Parineeta and Parvati' published in Star literature on 6 January, 2007. I could not keep myself from responding for a number of reasons. Firstly, I need to express my gratification over having found such sophisticated piece of movie criticism, which I believe is simultaneously the least flourishing genre with the most potential, especially in Bangladesh. In this regard, I would like to thank the editor of Star Literature and hope he publishes more such theoretically enthused criticisms in order to initiate a new trend.

Secondly, I really appreciate the perspective Ms. Sultana demonstrates to unearth the politics entailed in the construction of character, plot, and rhetoric of those two movies, Parineeta and Devdas, which she significantly relates to an yet-to-be-fully-discovered norm of violence against women. Undiscovered because, we have accustomed ourselves to encountering violence in movies where it is attributed with a bodily form, materialized by severe injury, death, destruction and caused by physical force or the like. Rebecca Sultana, on the other hand, regards the overall chauvinistic design of all narrative elements as more violent in the sense that the sustained ideology of this design is the frame from where violent motifs are derived. It also seems worth mentioning the way she dramatically confronts her own reception of Parineeta which she thinks is contaminated as a result of having been inculcated on so many occasions.

Additionally, while I agree completely with her methods and its contents, I feel the opposite is true regarding "Dr. Yunus's Nobel prize was especially welcome considering Grameen's reputation of working with disenfranchised women." Such an uncritical remark invalidates her analytical as well as political stance as it unwittingly once again adheres to another sort of representation, this time journalistic, missing all the politics that this mode might be involved with.

Sincerely

Rifat Munim Dip
Final Year, English Discipline
Khulna University